Blue Plate received multiple awards for food and service excellence.
- Winner of Best of Madison Magazine’s Best of Madison Award – 2005-2022
- Winner of WI Bride Magazine Best Caterer – 2017, 2020, 2021, 2022
- Winner of The Knot Best of Weddings – 2016-2018, 2020-2022
- Executive Choice Award Winner of In Business Magazine – 2017-2022
- 2019 Outstanding Small Business Award by In Business Magazine
- 2022 Dane County Small Business Award by In Business Magazine for business and philanthropic excellence
- 2020 Frontline Hero Award by NACE – Individual award given to David Porto for dedication and charity during Covid-19 and positively impacting the community